SOFT MACHINE LEGACY
''BURDEN OF PROOF''
MARCH 18 2013
5:08
1/Burden of Proof
John Etheridge/5:51
2/Voyage Beyond Seven
Theo Travis/4:53
3/Kitto
John Etheridge/1:50
4/Pie Chart
John Etheridge/5:07
5/JSP
John Marshall/1:02
6/Kings and Queens
Hugh Hopper/6:46
7/Fallout
Theo Travis/6:59
8/Going Somewhere Canorous?
Roy Babbington / John Marshall/1:13
9/Black and Crimson
Theo Travis/5:05
10/The Brief
John Marshall / Theo Travis/2:27
11/Pump Room
John Etheridge/5:19
12/Green Cubes
Roy Babbington / John Etheridge / John Marshall / Theo Travis/5:33
13/They Landed on a Hill
John Etheridge / Theo Travis/3:03
Roy Babbington/Bass
John Etheridge/Electric Guitar
John Marshall/Drums, Percussion
Theo Travis/Fender Rhodes, Flute, Piano, Sax (Tenor)
REVIEW
by Dave Lynch
Some fans could construe the title of 2013's Burden of Proof as a response from Soft Machine Legacy to occasional barbed comments from the peanut gallery. Consider first this group's apparent mission: maintaining the legacy of Soft Machine's 1970s jazz-rock years, a period when the Softs gradually replaced their psychedelic pop-era bandmembers with newcomers -- including drummer John Marshall, bassist Roy Babbington, and guitarist John Etheridge, all present here -- whom some regarded as Soft Machine "in name only." In a sense, naysayers placed a burden on these musicians to prove themselves worthy of the Soft Machine banner. Three decades later, four musicians with Soft Machine memberships scattered from 1969 through 1978 began playing together as Soft Machine Legacy, blurring their old band's lineup transitions while stylistically aligning themselves squarely on the jazzy side of the Soft Machine equation, in effect creating a come-together moment around the very music roundly criticized by fans devoted only to the group's '60s pop phase. Sadly, two of those musicians, saxophonist Elton Dean and bassist Hugh Hopper, died after the formation of the Legacy band, and with saxophonist/flutist/keyboardist Theo Travis and Babbington replacing them, this latest quartet almost seems destined to face questions about being Soft Machine Legacy in name only.
Yet at times on this album, questions about legacies and burdens of proof seem the furthest things from the bandmembers' minds. Babbington, Marshall, and Etheridge (all of whom appeared on the 1976 Soft Machine album Softs), along with Travis, already proved themselves to be a highly capable quartet on 2010's Live Adventures. On the studio-recorded Burden of Proof, the Softs legacy surfaces in a spacy version of Hopper's "Kings & Queens," with Travis on flute, and also in Travis' delay-echoed Fender Rhodes introduction to the leadoff title track, not to mention the tune's intersection of Babbington's streamlined modal walking bass with the sax-guitar unison melody line, as Marshall swings and rolls loosely through the tune's angularity. Elsewhere, several short bridging tracks provide atmosphere, and the group also ventures into lengthier group improvisations, sometimes searching, sometimes tumultuous, as on "Voyage Beyond Seven," "Green Cubes," and "Fallout," the latter bookended by a theme hinting at a fragmented "21st Century Schizoid Man," although far more relaxed. Again touching on the '70s Softs, Travis brings arpeggiated Rhodes into the intro and chorus of album highlight "Black and Crimson" -- also a showcase for Etheridge's wide vibrato-laden phrasing -- then pushes his tenor sax to the limit on the slam-bang sax-drums duo "The Brief," which also proves that Marshall can still be a percussive dynamo. But despite its jazzy interludes and heated interplay between Etheridge and Travis, "Pump Room" has a heavy boogie-rock beat, and the roadhouse jazz-blues-flavored "Pie Chart," with Travis wailing away R&B style, is about as far from the Soft Machine oeuvre as you could get. The bandmembers seem to be enjoying themselves, legacy be damned, and out to prove nothing except how to have a good time.
BIOGRAPHY
by Dave Lynch
In 1978, saxophonist Elton Dean and bassist Hugh Hopper got together with Canterbury scene buddies keyboardist Alan Gowen and drummer Pip Pyle to perform and record under a band moniker that quite justifiably referenced Soft Machine, the group that had brought Dean and Hopper the highest level of attention in their musical careers. The new group was named Soft Heap, and the music the quartet produced was a unique and noteworthy style of electric jazz fitting within neither the psychedelic pop nor the jazz-rock template of the ever-changing Soft Machine. Soft Heap recorded an eponymous studio album that year, released on the Charly label in 1979 (and getting the remastering treatment on a 2009 Esoteric CD reissue). And, in a sense, the group actually premiered on disc with 1978's live album Rogue Element, although the quartet used the moniker Soft Head on that release, since drummer Dave Sheen stood in for the unavailable Pyle on the recording (made during a French tour). Hugh, Elton, Alan, and Pip were the "HEAP"; Hugh, Elton, Alan, and Dave were the "HEAD."
Flash forward over two decades, all the way to 1999, and Dean and Hopper were back in another Soft Something group, Soft Ware, this time featuring a third Soft Machine alumnus, drummer John Marshall, along with free/avant jazz pianist Keith Tippett, who had his own performing and recording history with the saxophonist and bassist. This aggregation didn't issue an album, but it did signal that the story of Soft Machine alumni referencing their '60s-'70s internationally famous group wasn't over, and in the new millennium yet another outfit emerged to tap into the reservoir of Soft Machine fan interest: namely Soft Works, a quartet that released the 2003 album Abracadabra, featuring a somewhat spacy contemporary jazz flavor with Canterbury-esque and fusion leanings. This time, however, the group consisted entirely of previous Soft Machine members; in addition to Dean, Hopper, and Marshall, Soft Works included guitarist Allan Holdsworth. Although the four had all been in Soft Machine, no version of the Softs had included them at the same time, with Hopper appearing on albums Volume Two through Six; Dean on Third through Fifth; Holdsworth on Bundles; and Marshall on all the Softs albums from Fifth onward until the Karl Jenkins-led version of the group finally called it a day (around the same time that Dean and Hopper were playing in Soft Heap, as a matter of fact).
Holdsworth had left Soft Machine after one album, 1975's Bundles, and in somewhat characteristic fashion, he was gone from Soft Works after one album too. That left Dean, Hopper, and Marshall looking around for someone to replace him, and in an instance of history repeating itself, guitarist John Etheridge stepped up and plugged in, just as he had after Holdsworth departed Soft Machine following Bundles, when Etheridge signed on for 1976's Softs. So after Soft Heap, Soft Head, Soft Ware, and Soft Works, this new quartet took off in October 2004 under the name...Soft Machine Legacy. The quartet members apparently decided not to merely hint at the group that had given them their highest profiles in the music world -- Dean, Hopper, Marshall, and Etheridge came right out and said it in their band name: they were building on the legacy of Soft Machine. Moreover, although Soft Machine Legacy focused on new repertoire, they also began to revisit at least one old Soft Machine warhorse in their set list, "Kings & Queens," penned by Hopper and appearing on what some consider to be the peak recording of the Soft Machine "classic quartet" (Hopper, Dean, Mike Ratledge, Robert Wyatt), 1971's Fourth.
The MoonJune label began issuing Soft Machine Legacy albums with 2005's Live in Zaandam, recorded in May of that year in the Netherlands. It was followed by an eponymous studio album the following year, and then a pair of live releases from a December 2005 concert at the New Morning venue in Paris: the DVD New Morning: The Paris Concert, and the CD audio set Live at the New Morning; the New Morning concert included a version of "Seven for Lee," one of Dean's finest compositions featured on Soft Head's 1978 Rogue Element album. Sadly, however, Dean was in poor health and, although he planned to tour with Soft Machine Legacy in February 2006, he died that month at age 60.
Soft Machine Legacy vowed to continue following Dean's passing, and added saxophonist/flutist Theo Travis to the lineup for the group's next album, the 2007 studio album Steam. Although the group no longer exclusively featured musicians who had been in Soft Machine, Travis was an ideal choice for Soft Machine Legacy; he not only possessed serious jazz credibility, but had also performed and/or recorded with many artists linked to the same Canterbury scene that spawned Soft Machine, including Phil Miller's In Cahoots and latter-day versions of Gong and Hatfield and the North. But again, the old guard continued to pass away. The year after Steam was released, Hugh Hopper was diagnosed with leukemia, and he died in June 2009 at age 64. The two key members of Soft Machine who -- among many other projects over the years -- had maintained that group's spirit of adventurousness through Soft Heap/HEAD, Soft Ware, Soft Works, and Soft Machine Legacy, had both now passed on.
But the remaining three members of Soft Machine Legacy, drummer Marshall, guitarist Etheridge, and saxophonist/flutist Travis, again vowed to continue, and bassist Roy Babbington soon joined the lineup. Babbington had appeared as a guest on Soft Machine's Fourth (although he did not play bass on "Kings & Queens"), and had joined the band as a bona fide full member following the departure of Hopper during the group's Karl Jenkins years, appearing on 1973's Seven, 1975's Bundles with Allan Holdsworth, and 1976's Softs, the album that introduced John Etheridge to the lineup. Soft Machine Legacy now had three Soft Machine members who had appeared together on Softs: Etheridge, Marshall, and Babbington.
In October 2009, several months after Hopper's death, the latest version of the Soft Machine Legacy quartet set off on a European tour and recorded the album Live Adventures at dates in Germany and Austria; the album included a version of one of Hopper's best-known pieces, "Facelift," as well as two Karl Jenkins numbers, "The Nodder" and "Song of Aeolus." Live Adventures was released in 2010. Three years later, in early 2013, this lineup of the band returned with its first studio date, Burden of Proof, also released by MoonJune. The album featured all new compositions and improvisations aside from one track, a new rendition of "Kings & Queens."
DoWnLoAd
''BURDEN OF PROOF''
MARCH 18 2013
5:08
1/Burden of Proof
John Etheridge/5:51
2/Voyage Beyond Seven
Theo Travis/4:53
3/Kitto
John Etheridge/1:50
4/Pie Chart
John Etheridge/5:07
5/JSP
John Marshall/1:02
6/Kings and Queens
Hugh Hopper/6:46
7/Fallout
Theo Travis/6:59
8/Going Somewhere Canorous?
Roy Babbington / John Marshall/1:13
9/Black and Crimson
Theo Travis/5:05
10/The Brief
John Marshall / Theo Travis/2:27
11/Pump Room
John Etheridge/5:19
12/Green Cubes
Roy Babbington / John Etheridge / John Marshall / Theo Travis/5:33
13/They Landed on a Hill
John Etheridge / Theo Travis/3:03
Roy Babbington/Bass
John Etheridge/Electric Guitar
John Marshall/Drums, Percussion
Theo Travis/Fender Rhodes, Flute, Piano, Sax (Tenor)
REVIEW
by Dave Lynch
Some fans could construe the title of 2013's Burden of Proof as a response from Soft Machine Legacy to occasional barbed comments from the peanut gallery. Consider first this group's apparent mission: maintaining the legacy of Soft Machine's 1970s jazz-rock years, a period when the Softs gradually replaced their psychedelic pop-era bandmembers with newcomers -- including drummer John Marshall, bassist Roy Babbington, and guitarist John Etheridge, all present here -- whom some regarded as Soft Machine "in name only." In a sense, naysayers placed a burden on these musicians to prove themselves worthy of the Soft Machine banner. Three decades later, four musicians with Soft Machine memberships scattered from 1969 through 1978 began playing together as Soft Machine Legacy, blurring their old band's lineup transitions while stylistically aligning themselves squarely on the jazzy side of the Soft Machine equation, in effect creating a come-together moment around the very music roundly criticized by fans devoted only to the group's '60s pop phase. Sadly, two of those musicians, saxophonist Elton Dean and bassist Hugh Hopper, died after the formation of the Legacy band, and with saxophonist/flutist/keyboardist Theo Travis and Babbington replacing them, this latest quartet almost seems destined to face questions about being Soft Machine Legacy in name only.
Yet at times on this album, questions about legacies and burdens of proof seem the furthest things from the bandmembers' minds. Babbington, Marshall, and Etheridge (all of whom appeared on the 1976 Soft Machine album Softs), along with Travis, already proved themselves to be a highly capable quartet on 2010's Live Adventures. On the studio-recorded Burden of Proof, the Softs legacy surfaces in a spacy version of Hopper's "Kings & Queens," with Travis on flute, and also in Travis' delay-echoed Fender Rhodes introduction to the leadoff title track, not to mention the tune's intersection of Babbington's streamlined modal walking bass with the sax-guitar unison melody line, as Marshall swings and rolls loosely through the tune's angularity. Elsewhere, several short bridging tracks provide atmosphere, and the group also ventures into lengthier group improvisations, sometimes searching, sometimes tumultuous, as on "Voyage Beyond Seven," "Green Cubes," and "Fallout," the latter bookended by a theme hinting at a fragmented "21st Century Schizoid Man," although far more relaxed. Again touching on the '70s Softs, Travis brings arpeggiated Rhodes into the intro and chorus of album highlight "Black and Crimson" -- also a showcase for Etheridge's wide vibrato-laden phrasing -- then pushes his tenor sax to the limit on the slam-bang sax-drums duo "The Brief," which also proves that Marshall can still be a percussive dynamo. But despite its jazzy interludes and heated interplay between Etheridge and Travis, "Pump Room" has a heavy boogie-rock beat, and the roadhouse jazz-blues-flavored "Pie Chart," with Travis wailing away R&B style, is about as far from the Soft Machine oeuvre as you could get. The bandmembers seem to be enjoying themselves, legacy be damned, and out to prove nothing except how to have a good time.
BIOGRAPHY
by Dave Lynch
In 1978, saxophonist Elton Dean and bassist Hugh Hopper got together with Canterbury scene buddies keyboardist Alan Gowen and drummer Pip Pyle to perform and record under a band moniker that quite justifiably referenced Soft Machine, the group that had brought Dean and Hopper the highest level of attention in their musical careers. The new group was named Soft Heap, and the music the quartet produced was a unique and noteworthy style of electric jazz fitting within neither the psychedelic pop nor the jazz-rock template of the ever-changing Soft Machine. Soft Heap recorded an eponymous studio album that year, released on the Charly label in 1979 (and getting the remastering treatment on a 2009 Esoteric CD reissue). And, in a sense, the group actually premiered on disc with 1978's live album Rogue Element, although the quartet used the moniker Soft Head on that release, since drummer Dave Sheen stood in for the unavailable Pyle on the recording (made during a French tour). Hugh, Elton, Alan, and Pip were the "HEAP"; Hugh, Elton, Alan, and Dave were the "HEAD."
Flash forward over two decades, all the way to 1999, and Dean and Hopper were back in another Soft Something group, Soft Ware, this time featuring a third Soft Machine alumnus, drummer John Marshall, along with free/avant jazz pianist Keith Tippett, who had his own performing and recording history with the saxophonist and bassist. This aggregation didn't issue an album, but it did signal that the story of Soft Machine alumni referencing their '60s-'70s internationally famous group wasn't over, and in the new millennium yet another outfit emerged to tap into the reservoir of Soft Machine fan interest: namely Soft Works, a quartet that released the 2003 album Abracadabra, featuring a somewhat spacy contemporary jazz flavor with Canterbury-esque and fusion leanings. This time, however, the group consisted entirely of previous Soft Machine members; in addition to Dean, Hopper, and Marshall, Soft Works included guitarist Allan Holdsworth. Although the four had all been in Soft Machine, no version of the Softs had included them at the same time, with Hopper appearing on albums Volume Two through Six; Dean on Third through Fifth; Holdsworth on Bundles; and Marshall on all the Softs albums from Fifth onward until the Karl Jenkins-led version of the group finally called it a day (around the same time that Dean and Hopper were playing in Soft Heap, as a matter of fact).
Holdsworth had left Soft Machine after one album, 1975's Bundles, and in somewhat characteristic fashion, he was gone from Soft Works after one album too. That left Dean, Hopper, and Marshall looking around for someone to replace him, and in an instance of history repeating itself, guitarist John Etheridge stepped up and plugged in, just as he had after Holdsworth departed Soft Machine following Bundles, when Etheridge signed on for 1976's Softs. So after Soft Heap, Soft Head, Soft Ware, and Soft Works, this new quartet took off in October 2004 under the name...Soft Machine Legacy. The quartet members apparently decided not to merely hint at the group that had given them their highest profiles in the music world -- Dean, Hopper, Marshall, and Etheridge came right out and said it in their band name: they were building on the legacy of Soft Machine. Moreover, although Soft Machine Legacy focused on new repertoire, they also began to revisit at least one old Soft Machine warhorse in their set list, "Kings & Queens," penned by Hopper and appearing on what some consider to be the peak recording of the Soft Machine "classic quartet" (Hopper, Dean, Mike Ratledge, Robert Wyatt), 1971's Fourth.
The MoonJune label began issuing Soft Machine Legacy albums with 2005's Live in Zaandam, recorded in May of that year in the Netherlands. It was followed by an eponymous studio album the following year, and then a pair of live releases from a December 2005 concert at the New Morning venue in Paris: the DVD New Morning: The Paris Concert, and the CD audio set Live at the New Morning; the New Morning concert included a version of "Seven for Lee," one of Dean's finest compositions featured on Soft Head's 1978 Rogue Element album. Sadly, however, Dean was in poor health and, although he planned to tour with Soft Machine Legacy in February 2006, he died that month at age 60.
Soft Machine Legacy vowed to continue following Dean's passing, and added saxophonist/flutist Theo Travis to the lineup for the group's next album, the 2007 studio album Steam. Although the group no longer exclusively featured musicians who had been in Soft Machine, Travis was an ideal choice for Soft Machine Legacy; he not only possessed serious jazz credibility, but had also performed and/or recorded with many artists linked to the same Canterbury scene that spawned Soft Machine, including Phil Miller's In Cahoots and latter-day versions of Gong and Hatfield and the North. But again, the old guard continued to pass away. The year after Steam was released, Hugh Hopper was diagnosed with leukemia, and he died in June 2009 at age 64. The two key members of Soft Machine who -- among many other projects over the years -- had maintained that group's spirit of adventurousness through Soft Heap/HEAD, Soft Ware, Soft Works, and Soft Machine Legacy, had both now passed on.
But the remaining three members of Soft Machine Legacy, drummer Marshall, guitarist Etheridge, and saxophonist/flutist Travis, again vowed to continue, and bassist Roy Babbington soon joined the lineup. Babbington had appeared as a guest on Soft Machine's Fourth (although he did not play bass on "Kings & Queens"), and had joined the band as a bona fide full member following the departure of Hopper during the group's Karl Jenkins years, appearing on 1973's Seven, 1975's Bundles with Allan Holdsworth, and 1976's Softs, the album that introduced John Etheridge to the lineup. Soft Machine Legacy now had three Soft Machine members who had appeared together on Softs: Etheridge, Marshall, and Babbington.
In October 2009, several months after Hopper's death, the latest version of the Soft Machine Legacy quartet set off on a European tour and recorded the album Live Adventures at dates in Germany and Austria; the album included a version of one of Hopper's best-known pieces, "Facelift," as well as two Karl Jenkins numbers, "The Nodder" and "Song of Aeolus." Live Adventures was released in 2010. Three years later, in early 2013, this lineup of the band returned with its first studio date, Burden of Proof, also released by MoonJune. The album featured all new compositions and improvisations aside from one track, a new rendition of "Kings & Queens."
DoWnLoAd
